On May 2, 1960, on its ninth attempt, the State of California finally executed Caryl Chessman.
Terrence W. Cooney's Chessman, told in the liberating form of a factually-informed novel, introduces the reader to all the players in a long odyssey that brought such infamy to the state and country. From Governor Edmund "Pat" Brown to Chessman himself and to the landscape of a fast-changing California, Cooney anchors a chapter of the state's history that for too long has meandered a-sea. Many of the facats of this hysteria-inducing ordeal were gleaned from archival histories, both oral and written. And while much of the dialogue is imagined, the times, attendees, and days of the meetings that hosted such conversations are not.
In 1956, the author was appointed by the California Supreme Court to serve as counsel representing a defendant who had pleaded guilty to two murders. It was, Cooney knew from the start, a death penalty case. Cooney argued that the arbitrary imposition of the punishment violated the 1791 Eighth Amendment of the Constitution's Bill of Rights against "Cruel and Unusual Punishment." His argument was rejected. Subsequently, the U.S. Supreme Court adopted that position in 1972 when it so ruled that the arbitrary imposition of the death penalty constiuted cruel and unusual punishment.
Four years later, still unable to shake the case, Cooney had become engrossed by the Caryl Chessman affair that had started to become headline news throughout California and beyond. In 1960, Cooney produced the documentary: Justice and Caryl Chessman. The film was shown in more than 1,500 movie houses throughout the United States alone, and in countless theatres worldwide. During the filming of the documentary, Cooney met Chessman who was, at the time, the most famous resident of San Quentin's death row. In the process, Cooney also met and conversed with Chessman's attorneys, prosecutors, investigators and jailers.
Calls for clemency came from all over: Norman Mailer, Ray Bradbury, Robert Frost, former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt, and the Governor Brown's own son and future two-time California Governor Jerry Brown. So strong was the worldwide vitriol over Chessman's impending doom, that his eighth stay of execution was issued by Governor Brown mainly out of fear of retaliation against President Dwight Eisenhower who was scheduled to be traveling in South America at the time. Governor Edmund Brown later conceded that the Chessman affair cost him any real chance at a successful bid for the presidency of the United States of America.
After Chessman's execution, Cooney was able to meet former Governor Edmund "Pat" Brown and members of his staff. After fifty years, after decades of anger, hysteria and misinformation, Terrence W. Cooney has made the boldest move yet by placing all of these facts into the center of a novel that attempts to get to the heart of the matter.
~My thoughts~
I received a cover letter from the author along with a copy of this book to review. I was already interested in reading the book, but after reading the cover letter from the author I was even more so. He advised me that even though it is labeled as a fiction novel, there are actual facts, dates and persons involved. The author personally met with most of the people involved including the Governor and Mr. Chessman. I was also informed that even though Mr. Chessman was executed, he was never accused of a homicide. Any one who is for or against the death penalty should read this book. There have been over 250 convicted prisoners exonerated and released because of DNA testing results and most of them had been sentenced to execution. How many innocent people have been executed? Will we really ever know?
